Matthias Rath and Bad Science

I don't think I've ever had the occasion to congratulate a newspaper - usually exactly the opposite. But for this I think the Guardian (and Ben Goldacre) deserve serious congratulations both for courage under fire and responsible journalism:

Matthias Rath drops his million pound legal case against me and the Guardian.

The Guardian article is also well worth reading for more on Matthias Rath, the vitamin campaigner: Fall of the doctor who said his vitamins would cure Aids


Speaking of bad science, I was upset to hear the name Danie Krugel mentioned in a news report on the search for missing local girl Kerry Winter (Kerry recently went missing in Dubai in seriously dodgy circumstances, and has not yet been found). Danie Krugel is a charlatan of note and a South African embarrassment, famous for his "Matter Oriented System" or MOS which he claims can locate anything from missing people to diamonds and bacteria using "quantum physics, GPS Technology and DNA samples". Despite being proved a fake time and time again, he keeps making it into the media. It wouldn't be so upsetting if he didn't give desperate people false hope.

Update: Subtle Shift in Emphasis has a great write-up on Danie Krugel, his voodoo science claims and his growing list of public failures. Also a growing list (and surrounding discussion) on the South African skeptics forum.

2 Comments

Well put. I wish the local media would learn a bit from Ben Goldacre and responsible journalism, instead of just acting as a mouthpiece for any crackpot that says something sensational. Why do most bloggers know more about DK's false claims than professional mainstream journalists?

Well, the bloggers have united and created a site to actively fight Krugel's continued promotion. See www.stopdaniekrugel.com

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by ewan published on September 14, 2008 4:43 PM.

Hannah Grace McPhail arrives was the previous entry in this blog.

Why I Love My Country is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Recent Entries

  • Snapshot, 2008

    2008 was a huge year for my family and I. Here goes recording some of the best parts, and a snapshot of my life as...

  • Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays

    Merry Christmas and happy holidays all. This has been a wonderful year for me - full of changes, new opportunities and the birth of...

  • Seaside baptisms - handle with care

    City of Durban council safety tips during the festive season:Wear clothing made of light material as heavy clothing will cause you to sinkAnimals are not...

  • Chemical Pollution Destroying Masculinity, not Humour

    As usual the comments are the best part of today's Slashdot coverage of a new study claiming that "A host of common chemicals is feminizing...

  • Derivco hosting SEAS in December

    Derivco will be hosting a SQL Server Enterprise Architectural Summit in December. Speakers are Stuart Ozer, Gert Drapers and Thomas Kejser (members of the Microsoft SQL...

OpenID accepted here Learn about OpenID

Action Stream

...more (current)
Afrigator
Close